"Tell me that's all it is," Helene Karlin remembers saying to the
ophthalmologist who diagnosed poor vision as the cause of her seven-week old
daughter Lindsay's slow development. "Tell me I don't have to worry about
anything else." Despite his reassurances, she suspected a more serious
problem. But nothing prepared Helene or Roger Karlin for the shock of
being told that their daughter would die of Canavan Disease.
Nor did they find many resources to help them cope afterward. "There was no
literature, no treatment being developed, no funding for research…nothing,"
Helene recalls, frustration still evident in her voice. Roger, an internist,
combated his growing sense of helplessness by spending thousands of hours on the
phone, exhausting his ties in the medical community to track down "everyone
under the sun who had anything to do with genetics." He met with researchers
around the country to consider possibilities for developing a treatment.
Finally, in the fall of 1994, Drs. Roger and Helene Karlin met with Dr. Matthew During and Dr.
Paola Leone at Yale University and inspired them to attempt to develop a
gene therapy approach. Within a year and a half, they had developed a vector system to transport the new genes into
brain cells. These new genes were then administered into the ventricles (the
area between the brain where spinal fluid flows) of Lindsay and another affected
child, Alyssa Mushin.
The gene therapy was performed in Auckland, New Zealand on March 6, 1996 and was the
world's first gene therapy for a genetic brain disease. Both children showed
remarkable improvements, including increased alertness, improved vision and stronger
head control. They had awakened to the world.
News of the research spread quickly: it was featured on “Sixty Minutes” and
“The CBS Morning Show” as well as in The New York Times, TIME Magazine, and on
the cover of The South China Morning Post (a prominent Asian newspaper), opposite
Bob Dole’s bid for the presidency. As more families learned of the
research, they, too, joined the cause. The Canavan Research Foundation took on
the task of raising funds, of tackling regulatory roadblocks, and of being the
champions for their children. After a year and a half of various delays, the
same gene therapy, slightly modified, was approved by the FDA in January of 1998
to be used in a second experimental trial at Yale University and Jefferson Medical
College. Sixteen children ranging in age from 9 months to 7 years were treated in the first
clinical trial for a genetic brain disease in the United States All of the children showed
improvement, and the results have been published in various scientific journals. Meanwhile, the
research for Canavan Disease was recognized in the Human Genome Exhibit at the Museum of Natural
History in New York for its role in advancing gene therapy to cure disease.
The most recent advances have been especially exciting. Impressed with the potential of this research to cure
a multitude of diseases, the National Institute of
Health awarded Dr. Leone's laboratory the first clinical grant for gene therapy of the brain.
Using a new and more potent viral vector, the gene was surgically injected into six areas of the brain
in eight Canavan children to disperse throughout the cerebrospinal fluid and take over for the defective
gene. Younger children, who can reap the greatest benefit, have recently been enrolled in the trial. Many of
the treated children have been monitored, and the parents of each and every child are reporting clinical improvement.
Lindsay, now eleven years old, has had no deterioration in the four years since she was last treated
and is able to use a specially-equipped bicycle. Another child is able to drive his own powered wheelchair.
Researchers expect to use findings from this study to apply to more common diseases such as Parkinson's, Alzheimer's
and stroke. In fact, what began in 1995 as a small-scale research effort has evolved into research that may change the
face of medicine within the next several years.
Due to the simplicity of the defective gene mechanism, Canavan Disease is also a good prototype for stem cell research.
The Foundation is currently supporting researchers who have demonstrated the greatest potential to bring their work to
clinical trial in the next two years, including a stem cell research protocol headed by Dr. Paola Leone that will
hopefully culminate in a clinical trial by the spring of 2007. Stem cell therapy has the potential to repair damage
caused by many diseases and traumas; in addition to Canavan and related diseases, stem cell therapy may also prove an
effective treatment for multiple sclerosis, stroke and traumatic brain and spinal cord injury.